I don't think the chef should obey the law of the kings because well first the chefs in the dungeon and she loves the soup so does desperaux even the princess pea liked soup
I think Cook should of been punished because she made soup. The reason I think she should been punished is because soup is not allowed in the palace. Cook should not of made soup because King Philip maybe would have came in and sent her to the dungeon.
I don't think that cook should be punished. I think that if i was in Cook's shoes I would be doing exactly the same thing. I mean the princess has been kidnapped, I would be freaking out. So all in all she should not be punished, she is going through as much stress as (the king not included) everybody else.
I disagree with the cook in the dungeon because it said nothing about the cook in the dungeon. When cook was making the soup cook as in the kitchen. I know this because for 1) it never said cook went to the dungeon and for 2) there is no kitchen in the dungeon
I don't think he should be punished.If I was a cook I would have the same thing. and the king is going through a rough time because the princess has been kidnapped.
I don't think cook should of been punished because she was just upset that the princess was missing and that maybe it was time to brake one of the rules to make herself feel a little happiness. I think it was proved on page 232. I think that it was proved by the first few dialogue parts when the cook says." And when times are terrible soup is the answer. Don't it smell like the answer"
I agree with Elyse and the rest who don't agree that she should be punished because like Elyse said the cook just wanted to let off some steam.I mean it's not like the cook hurt anyone physically except of course Despereaux's tail and all,but that is not my point my point is that the cook shouldn't be punished.
Cook should not be punished for what she did. Of course it is the law but I think (just my opinion) that if the king came out of his room while she was making the instead of sending her to the dungeon he would want a taste, even though he the king would be breaking the law. He might of stopped making soup outlawed(even though he does in the end of the story end of the story).
No because Cook just probably just needed to have a little taste of the soup.
ReplyDeleteI don't think the chef should obey the law of the kings because well first the chefs in the dungeon and she loves the soup so does desperaux even the princess pea liked soup
ReplyDeleteRegardless of what they like, shouldn't they still be accountable for the laws of the land? Why would they be allowed to break the law?
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteI disagree with orlando because they might take him to the dungeon and he might not survive
DeleteI think Cook should of been punished because she made soup. The reason I think she should been punished is because soup is not allowed in the palace. Cook should not of made soup because King Philip maybe would have came in and sent her to the dungeon.
ReplyDeleteI don't think that cook should be punished. I think that if i was in Cook's shoes I would be doing exactly the same thing. I mean the princess has been kidnapped, I would be freaking out. So all in all she should not be punished, she is going through as much stress as (the king not included) everybody else.
ReplyDeleteDoes stress entitle a person to do illegal things?
DeleteIf that were the case, the world would be quite chaotic!
Didn't think about that
DeleteOf course not he should not be punished for making soup. Cook was making soup it was thee qweens favorite food in the Kingdom Dor.
ReplyDeleteInteresting thought Danna. Since it was the queen's favorite it should be honored.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThe chef is in the dungeon.she has the love of soup.And the king can't see the chef anyway
ReplyDeleteI disagree with the cook in the dungeon because it said nothing about the cook in the dungeon. When cook was making the soup cook as in the kitchen. I know this because for 1) it never said cook went to the dungeon and for 2) there is no kitchen in the dungeon
Deleteyes because cook knows that cooking or eating the soup is outlawed in the kingdom of Dor so she should be punished.
ReplyDeleteThe chef shouldn't be punished because she made soup in the dungeon
ReplyDeleteThe cook might have just missed it so he just wanted to taste it because he just haven't eaten it in a while and missed having it around
ReplyDeleteI think cook should obey the kings law because cook can be threw in to the dungeon. In the dark, rat filled, smelly, and evil dungeon.
ReplyDeleteI don't think he should be punished.If I was a cook I would have the same thing.
ReplyDeleteand the king is going through a rough time because the princess has been kidnapped.
I don't think cook should of been punished because she was just upset that the princess was missing and that maybe it was time to brake one of the rules to make herself feel a little happiness. I think it was proved on page 232. I think that it was proved by the first few dialogue parts when the cook says." And when times are terrible soup is the answer. Don't it smell like the answer"
ReplyDeleteI agree with Elyse and the rest who don't agree that she should be punished because like Elyse said the cook just wanted to let off some steam.I mean it's not like the cook hurt anyone physically except of course Despereaux's tail and all,but that is not my point my point is that the cook shouldn't be punished.
ReplyDeleteHow do you think that the cook was letting steam of?
ReplyDeleteI think the chef should be sent to the dungeon because she was making soup.Although the story would have changed.
ReplyDeleteCook should not be punished for what she did. Of course it is the law but I think (just my opinion) that if the king came out of his room while she was making the instead of sending her to the dungeon he would want a taste, even though he the king would be breaking the law. He might of stopped making soup outlawed(even though he does in the end of the story end of the story).
ReplyDeleteWell Elyse if your Pricess was missing(if you were in the story) wouldn't you want to let of some steam?
ReplyDeleteI disagree with the dungeon because on page 228 cook says " A mouse in my kitchen"
ReplyDeleteand it said nothing of the cook in the dungeon cooking soup.